To be honest, I saw a programme a couple of days ago on TV which I instantly knew I wanted to blog about, but the subject was so complex and controversial that I spent the whole of yesterday trying to decide what to say about it. The Great ADHD Myth is the kind of television which is always going to split opinions: my problem is, I know what I think about it, but I’m not sure I know enough about the subject to fully articulate and justify those opinions. Broadly speaking, the gist of the documentary is that Attention Deficit and Hyperactivity Disorder doesn’t really exist as a medical condition, but is just a vague list of symptoms which people are increasingly ascribing to children. I certainly agree: as far as I can make out, such kids don’t have any sort of neurological disorder, but were simply never taught to pay attention and stay focussed on what they need to do. It’s just a matter of childhood discipline. When I was little, my brothers and I were always taught that we needed to finish our schoolwork before we could go and play, or that we wouldn’t get any pudding unless we finished our main meal. These days, however, kids seem to be being allowed to get away with whatever they like; and when they start to play up, rather than being told to behave, their parents start to claim that they have a medical condition.
I probably sound like a grumpy old man for writing that. I know there will be people who resolutely disagree with it, and will be very angry that the programme was aired. To them, ADHD is very, very real, and to have it’s existence and validity contested will seem like a challenge to their identities. Indeed, according to this BBC article, ADHD UK has complained to Ofcom about the programme, saying: “ADHD is not a myth. It is not a social construct.” Yet I think this speaks to something which is becoming increasingly obvious these days: people seem to be becoming increasingly eager to compartmentalise themselves, and categorise and pathologise behaviours which would previously be seen as perfectly normal as medical conditions. It’s as if being normal is no longer cool, so everybody is starting to claim to have a condition or disability. As someone who has had a clear-cut, unambiguous disability all his life, it’s frankly becoming increasingly insulting. I’m just glad to see that other people are starting to pick up on it.





