I just saw in the morning news that Justin Welby has been making pronouncements about british politics: in a new year’s address, he called on politicians to treat one another humanely and to “treat political opponents as human beings”. I’m sorry, but I have to say things like this really, really piss me off. As I wrote here, Welby is a man who nobody voted for, whose only authority stems from an ancient, anachronistic belief system; yet he claims a right to speak on national TV and radio, and to tell politicians how to act like some sage old wizard who we should all venerate. That strikes me as obscene. After all, if everyone saw the set of myths which Welby and religious figures like him derive their authority from as the baseless hogwash they are, he would just be ignored like every other lunatic spouting nonsense about their imaginary friends.
Instead, because religion, and christianity in particular, still has so much of a hold over our culture, primarily because the church won’t allow us to call it out as the nonsense it is, such men can tell others what to think and how to act, including our politicians. That strikes me as both extremely arrogant and undemocratic: surely in any modern democracy, political authority should stem from the population, not religion. Welby and preachers like him (note that I refuse to use their self-proclaimed religious titles) have no right to make judgements and pronouncements about politics, and such pronouncements certainly shouldn’t be aired on the morning news.
Blimey, barely a morning into the year and I’m already ranting about politics.
What is objectionable about “he called on politicians to treat one another humanely and to “treat political opponents as human beings?” Many people speak on TV and radio with whom others disagree. It is the BBC who asked him to comment. Welby also was an important business executive prior to entering the church as a career. In this case he made no attempt to proselytize.
You constantly bang on about Lord of the Rings. This is what Tolkien said about it: “The Lord of the Rings is of course a fundamentally religious and Catholic work; unconsciously so at first, but consciously in the revision.” There is something to rant about.
LikeLike
I suppose I just have major problems with being told what to think and how to behave by people who demand a form of unquestionable social authority, simply by invoking a set of myths and creation stories which the merest analysis can show to be absurd. Religion has held humanity back for centuries: it divides communities and controls people. What Welby said may have seemed harmless and benign, but the fact that it was covered on TV, as if he was an elected politician, just awards him a status he does not deserve.
As for Tolkien, I know he was a devout catholic, but that does not interfere too much in his writing, as far as I can tell.
LikeLike